1. Go to onRecord > Settings > Grading > Grade Translations
  2. Add the grades with the asterisk to the Grade Translation and in the grade labels add the asterisks and numeric grade.
  3. Create a new Grade Category for the grades with the asterisks
  4. Check off Translate Score on Input as well as Translate Score on Output > Save & Exit
  5. Once this is done, go to the grade plan and select the new Grade Category to be added to the Grade Plan