Prior to creating a case, verify when the participant registered and when the Kintera Thon event was made Active. If this participant registered while the event was in Preview mode, and the site was later made Active, then their registration entry would have been removed, and this is why they do not appear.
If the participant registered while the event was Active, and they can not be found:
Chat With Support and reference this article.
Connect and collaborate with fellow Blackbaud users.